Month 2 Of My Reading Challenge by Frances Colville

I began with a book I probably wouldn’t have picked up myself, but which was the book of choice for one of my two reading groups.The Girl Under The Olive Tree by Leah Fleming (published Simon and Schuster UK 2013). It should have been a good read (interesting storyline about an English nurse working for the resistance in Crete during WW2) but there were some irritating anomalies and frequent failures to capitalise on opportunities for dramatic tension. I was left feeling dissatisfied, though I did learn some fascinating facts about Crete and WW2.

MONTH 2 OF MY READING CHALLENGE by Frances Colville

My second book also failed to grab me fully. I recently went to a talk by author Natasha Solomons and thought she spoke well and interestingly. I picked up a copy of The Gallery of Vanished Husbands(published Sceptre 2013) and keenly anticipated reading it. But I wasn’t completely convinced by her portrayal of the main character and I found the plot unrealistic in places. However, it is well written; her use of language appealed to me, as did the pace of the book, and there are some excellent descriptive passages. I think I will try another of her books. One more to add to my list.

MONTH 2 OF MY READING CHALLENGE by Frances Colville   2
Next I moved on to another reading group choice: The Year of Wonders by Geraldine Brooks(published Fourth Estate 2002). This was in fact a re-read for me, but I relished the opportunity to have a fresh look at a book which has long been on my Top Ten List. It’s based on the true story of a Derbyshire village coping with an outbreak of plague in the seventeenth century and is one of those books which is almost unbearable to read, and yet equally you can hardly bear to put it down.

MONTH 2 OF MY READING CHALLENGE by Frances Colville   3

As an aspiring short story and flash fiction writer, I have been eagerly awaiting the chance to read Hilary Mantel’s new short story collection The Assassination of Margaret Thatcher(published Fourth Estate 2014) and I wasn’t disappointed. Each individual story is a compelling read and all are powerful, harrowing, disturbing and haunting. In fact they made me question why I read. Is it for pleasure and relaxation? To learn? To be challenged? Or to appreciate the skill of the writer? In the case of this book, I think it is the latter two. And that is a tribute to Hilary Mantel who is a supremely good writer.

MONTH 2 OF MY READING CHALLENGE by Frances Colville   4

After that, I needed something less stressful and turned to Claire Sandy’s novel What Would Mary Berry Do?(published Pan Books 2014) Who doesn’t love Mary Berry and the Bake Off programmes? I’m a big fan, and this lighthearted tale of a harassed mother teaching herself with Mary Berry’s help to bake appealed to me. In fact I could have done with a bit more of the baking and a bit less of the rest of the story. It isn’t a book that will stick in my mind for years to come, but it is an enjoyable and relaxing read and I definitely recommend it if that’s the sort of book you’re looking for.

It’s a truism to say variety is the spice of life, but I’m learning that my choice of books reflects just that. So now I have a problem. What to pick up first for month 3?

 

 

My Reading Challenge by Frances Colville

How many books can you read in a year?  It recently occurred to me that life is far too short to read everything I want to read.  There simply aren’t enough hours in the day or years in a lifetime.  So I’ve set myself a challenge for 2015 – to be organised about what I read, to make deliberate choices and above all to emphasis variety.  But there has to be quality there too.  I haven’t any time to waste.

bookreviewbookreviews1

So here’s the pick of the books I’ve read in January.  First up were two Agatha Christie novels. The first, Ordeal by Innocence was a re-read and the second, Death in the Clouds, new to me.  I thoroughly enjoyed both.  For me Agatha Christie is a master craftsman, able to weave together the intricate threads of a plot in remarkably few words, and at the same time create a view of her world with all its idiosyncrasies.  Agatha Christie paperbacks are readily available in secondhand bookshops.

books

Next I moved on to Stoner by John Williams (First published 1965, Vintage classic reprint 2012).  Another brilliantly crafted book and a beautifully written one, it tells the story of William Stoner, an American academic, who seems to stumble through life with a sense of not being quite sure what he is actually doing there.   I was hooked from the first page although it’s hard to analyse why.  Perhaps it’s just simply enough to say I recognised him.  I would like to have known him.

bookreviews3

And then something completely different; a memoir entitled Love, Nina written by Nina Stibbe (Penguin paperback 2014) telling the story of the time she spent as a nanny for a family in London in the 1980s.  This well written and very humorous book particularly resonated with me as I too worked as a nanny for a London family in my gap year.  Nina Stibbe has a delightfully light and self-deprecating voice and a casual way of dropping big names (Alan Bennett and Jonathan Miller for example) into her writing, adding both depth and interest.  I see she has also written a novel and I look forward to checking that out – though maybe not this year.

bookreviewsgoodwives

My final book this month was Margaret Forster’s Good Wives?  (Vintage paperback 2002) With a mixture of biographical writing, and personal reflection, Forster tells the story of three ‘good wives’ from different times (Mary Livingstone,  Fanny Stevenson and  Jennie Lee) and tries to work out just what it is that makes a good wife.  It’s an interesting premise for a book, and generally a good  read, though it suffers from being neither biography nor memoir, falling somewhere between the two.  Perhaps inevitably I am left feeling dissatisfied and wanting to know more – about the people whose stories she tells and about her.

 

So I end the month by adding yet more books to my list – further biographies of the three ladies, and re-reads of Margaret Forster’s novels.  Not quite what I’d originally planned.